HistoricalChristian.Faith

Tertullian and the Power of the Keys

Dates: c. 210 (De Pudicitia / On Modesty, from Tertullian’s Montanist years, c. 208–212; De Praescriptione Haereticorum / The Prescription Against Heretics is earlier, c. 200) · Wikipedia
Summary: Tertullian of Carthage (c. 155–c. 220) supplies the timeline’s earliest explicit denial that the Petrine commission of Matthew 16 passes as a standing jurisdiction to the bishop of Rome. In On Modesty (De Pudicitia), written after he had joined the rigorist Montanist (“New Prophecy”) movement and turned against the mainstream (“psychic”) church, he ridicules a Roman bishop’s edict absolving adultery and fornication — mocking its author as “Pontifex Maximus — that is, the bishop of bishops” — and argues at length (ch. 21) that the keys and the power of binding and loosing were given to Peter personally, or to spiritual men, and were not transmitted to “every Church akin to Peter,” least of all to “the Church which consists of a number of bishops.” This is placed on the timeline as a counter-datum: c. 210 the inference from the Matthew 16 keys to a Roman jurisdiction was already being contested head-on. The honest complication — kept in full view below — is that this is the polemical, schismatic Tertullian; the same author, a decade earlier and still in the catholic church, had appealed warmly to Rome’s double-apostolic pedigree (The Prescription Against Heretics 32, 36). Both are reported here; the shift is itself part of the evidence.

Related doctrines: the keys and binding-and-loosing of Matthew 16:19 / 18:18 that Tertullian confines to Peter are the founding proof-texts weighed in the summary’s Arguments section; Tertullian’s wider quarrel with the “psychic” church over who may forgive sins touches the ministerial priesthood.

Claims & evidence

The mocked edict: “Pontifex Maximus — that is, the bishop of bishops” (De Pudicitia 1)

Tertullian opens On Modesty by rounding on a recent edict — issued, on the usual identification, by Callistus of Rome (bishop c. 217–222; some scholars place the treatise a little earlier under Zephyrinus) — that offered church reconciliation to penitent adulterers and fornicators. Tertullian’s sarcasm fastens on the grandeur of the claim behind it:

I hear that there has even been an edict set forth, and a peremptory one too. The Pontifex Maximus — that is, the bishop of bishops — issues an edict: “I remit, to such as have discharged (the requirements of) repentance, the sins both of adultery and of fornication.” O edict, on which cannot be inscribed, “Good deed!” … But it is in the church that this (edict) is read, and in the church that it is pronounced; and (the church) is a virgin!

— On Modesty 1.1 The titles are thrown as taunts, not conceded as descriptions: Tertullian’s point is that no bishop — however styled “bishop of bishops” — has the power he is arrogating. The passage is doubly useful to the primacy timeline. It shows a Roman bishop, c. 210, evidently making a sweeping claim to remit even capital sins by his own sentence; and it shows that claim being met with open ridicule by a leading Latin churchman, who treats “bishop of bishops” as a pretension to be exposed rather than an office to be obeyed.

The keys were given to Peter personally, not to Rome’s see (De Pudicitia 21)

In the treatise’s theological core, Tertullian confronts the proof-text directly. If Rome grounds its power to bind and loose on what Christ said to Peter in Matthew 16, then (he argues) it has misread the plain grammar of the grant: every clause is singular, spoken to Peter:

If, because the Lord has said to Peter, “Upon this rock will I build My Church,” “to thee have I given the keys of the heavenly kingdom;” or, “Whatsoever thou shalt have bound or loosed in earth, shall be bound or loosed in the heavens,” you therefore presume that the power of binding and loosing has derived to you, that is, to every Church akin to Peter, what sort of man are you, subverting and wholly changing the manifest intention of the Lord, conferring (as that intention did) this (gift) personally upon Peter? “On thee,” He says, “will I build My Church;” and, “I will give to thee the keys,” not to the Church; and, “Whatsoever thou shalt have loosed or bound,” not what they shall have loosed or bound.

— On Modesty 21.2 He then makes the grant self-exhausting in Peter’s own acts: “In (Peter) himself the Church was reared … (Peter) himself essayed the key” — unlocking the kingdom to Israel at Pentecost and to the nations at the Jerusalem council. And he draws the conclusion the primacy reading cannot use: whatever power over sins the keys convey belongs, on the pattern of Peter, to spiritual men — a prophet or apostle of the Spirit — and precisely not to a college of bishops:

And accordingly “the Church,” it is true, will forgive sins: but (it will be) the Church of the Spirit, by means of a spiritual man; not the Church which consists of a number of bishops. For the right and arbitrament is the Lord’s, not the servant’s; God’s Himself, not the priest’s.

— On Modesty 21.3 This is the sharpest early statement of a reading the summary’s Arguments weigh in detail: that the Matthew 16 keys were a personal endowment of Peter, not a jurisdiction handed down through a see. What Tertullian denies is not that Peter received a unique key — he insists on it — but that Rome’s bishop is the standing heir of it.

The earlier Tertullian: Rome doubly apostolic (The Prescription Against Heretics 32, 36)

The counter-datum has its own counter-weight, and honesty requires it be shown. A decade before, while still in the catholic church and writing against the Gnostics, Tertullian had appealed to the apostolic churches — Rome chief among them — as living guarantors of the true tradition. He cites Rome’s succession from Peter as a model of authentic pedigree:

… as the church of Smyrna, which records that Polycarp was placed therein by John; as also the church of Rome, which makes Clement to have been ordained in like manner by Peter.

— The Prescription Against Heretics 32.4 And in ch. 36 he sends the inquirer to the apostolic sees whose thrones still stand, ending with Rome — the church that heard both Peter and Paul, and holds a doubled apostolic authority:

Since, moreover, you are close upon Italy, you have Rome, from which there comes even into our own hands the very authority (of apostles themselves). How happy is its church, on which apostles poured forth all their doctrine along with their blood! where Peter endures a passion like his Lord’s! where Paul wins his crown in a death like John’s …

— The Prescription Against Heretics 36.5 The pre-Montanist Tertullian thus honours Rome’s apostolic standing as fully as any early Western witness — but note what he honours it as: an apostolic church, one specimen (alongside Corinth, Philippi, Ephesus) of the many sees where the apostles’ own teaching can be checked, and grounded in Peter and Paul jointly. Even here the accent falls on Rome’s doctrinal reliability, not on a transmitted Petrine jurisdiction; and he attributes the founding not to a bishop-Peter but to Peter’s ordaining of Clement.

Notes

Sources


  1. Tertullian, On Modesty (De Pudicitia) 1 (Roberts–Donaldson translation, Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. IV; also read locally in On Modesty): “I hear that there has even been an edict set forth, and a peremptory one too. The Pontifex Maximus — that is, the bishop of bishops — issues an edict: ‘I remit, to such as have discharged (the requirements of) repentance, the sins both of adultery and of fornication.’” ↩

  2. Tertullian, On Modesty (De Pudicitia) 21 (Roberts–Donaldson translation, ANF Vol. IV): “If, because the Lord has said to Peter, ‘Upon this rock will I build My Church,’ ‘to thee have I given the keys of the heavenly kingdom’ … you therefore presume that the power of binding and loosing has derived to you, that is, to every Church akin to Peter, what sort of man are you, subverting and wholly changing the manifest intention of the Lord, conferring (as that intention did) this (gift) personally upon Peter? ‘On thee,’ He says, ‘will I build My Church;’ and, ‘I will give to thee the keys,’ not to the Church.” ↩

  3. Tertullian, On Modesty (De Pudicitia) 21 (Roberts–Donaldson translation, ANF Vol. IV): “And accordingly ‘the Church,’ it is true, will forgive sins: but (it will be) the Church of the Spirit, by means of a spiritual man; not the Church which consists of a number of bishops. For the right and arbitrament is the Lord’s, not the servant’s; God’s Himself, not the priest’s.” ↩

  4. Tertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics (De Praescriptione Haereticorum) 32 (Roberts–Donaldson translation, Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. III; also read locally in The Prescription Against Heretics): “as also the church of Rome, which makes Clement to have been ordained in like manner by Peter.” ↩

  5. Tertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics (De Praescriptione Haereticorum) 36 (Roberts–Donaldson translation, ANF Vol. III): “Since, moreover, you are close upon Italy, you have Rome, from which there comes even into our own hands the very authority (of apostles themselves). How happy is its church, on which apostles poured forth all their doctrine along with their blood! where Peter endures a passion like his Lord’s! where Paul wins his crown in a death like John’s.” ↩