Dates: c. 210 (the monogamist treatises) · Wikipedia
Summary: Tertullian is the hard pole of the Latin tradition. Where Paul permits the
widowed to remarry, Tertullian — in his later, openly Montanist works — forbids it outright and brands
the second marriage “a species of fornication.” His position sharpened in stages: from the early
To His Wife, which urges widowhood while conceding remarriage is lawful, to On Monogamy, which
makes it a sin the Paraclete has forbidden.
…the Apostle… permits marrying indeed, but prefers abstinence; the former on account of the snares of temptations, the latter on account of the straits of the times.
— Tertullian, To His Wife I.3, ANF vol. 4. Written to his own wife against the day of his death, the treatise urges her to remain a widow but concedes that second marriage is a lawful thing, only depreciated — and confines the disability of the twice-married to church office and the widows’ order, which is still the catholic line.
If we look deeply into his meanings, and interpret them, second marriage will have to be termed no other than a species of fornication.
— Tertullian, On Exhortation to Chastity 9, ANF vol. 4. Addressed to a recently widowed friend to dissuade him from remarrying, the chapter reasons from the concupiscence marriage shares with fornication. The counsel of the earlier treatise has now hardened into a prohibition, and the remarriage of a widow or widower is classed as stuprum.
…why may not the Paraclete, too, have abrogated an indulgence which Paul granted — because second marriage withal ‘was not from the beginning’…?
— Tertullian, On Monogamy 14, ANF vol. 4. When he has to reckon with Paul’s plain permission, Tertullian does not out-argue it but overrides it by a higher warrant: the New Prophecy as restitutor of a stricter original rule, licensed to cancel an apostolic concession. Where that will not serve, he claims at On Monogamy 11 that the Greek of 1 Cor. 7:39 was corrupted “through the either crafty or simple alteration of two syllables” so as to restrict Paul’s permission to women already widowed at their conversion — a textual charge weighed, and found unsupported, on the “was 1 Cor. 7:39 corrupted?” argument: no Greek witness carries his restriction, and his own words locate the difference in a Latin rendering, not a corrupted Greek exemplar.