Dates: 1640 (his Augustinus, published posthumously) / 1653 (its condemnation) ·
Cornelius Jansen (Jansenius), bishop of Ypres, 1585–1638 ·
Wikipedia
Summary: A Dutch-born theologian who spent more than twenty years mining Augustine, Cornelius Jansen
died bishop of Ypres in 1638 leaving behind a vast Latin folio, the Augustinus, published by his friends in
1640. In it he revived Augustine’s hardest teaching in its most rigorist form: fallen human nature is so mastered
by concupiscence that the will is “purely passive,” swept along by whichever “delectation”
— heavenly grace or earthly desire — happens to be the stronger; grace, when God gives it, is intrinsically
efficacious and never resisted, so that a merely “sufficient” grace that does not in fact suffice is a
fiction; and Christ died for the elect alone. Where Fulgentius and
Gottschalk had pressed Augustine hard from within the medieval church, Jansen
pressed him past the line Rome would allow: in 1653 Innocent X’s bull Cum occasione condemned five
propositions drawn from the book. If Orange (529) fixed the Catholic boundary
against the semi-Pelagian softening of grace, Cum occasione fixed the opposite boundary against an
over-Augustinian denial of the will — and touched off a century of controversy (Port-Royal, Arnauld, Pascal, the
“formulary”) over whether the condemned propositions were really in Jansen’s book at all.
At once inevitable and irresistible, this delectation, if it come from heaven or from grace, leads man to virtue; if it come from nature or concupiscence, it determines him to sin. In the one case as in the other, the will is fatally swept on by the preponderant impulse. The two delectations, says Jansenius, are like the two arms of a balance, of which the one cannot rise unless the other be lowered and vice versa.
— Cornelius Jansen, Augustinus (1640), as characterized (with the “two arms of a balance” image attributed to Jansen) in the Catholic Encyclopedia, “Jansenius and Jansenism,” source.1 On Jansen’s reading of Augustine, the fallen will is not a scale that weighs and chooses but one that is simply tipped: “the will is powerless to resist; it has become purely passive.” Grace and concupiscence are two competing delights, and the stronger always wins — “man irresistibly, although voluntarily, does either good or evil, according as he is dominated by grace or by concupiscence.” From this it follows, Jansen argued, that there is “no place for purely sufficient grace”: grace either conquers or is not given. (These theses are reported here from the standard reference literature; no English translation of the massive Latin Augustinus itself is quoted directly on this page.)
1. Some of God’s precepts are impossible to the just, who wish and strive to keep them, according to the present powers which they have; the grace, by which they are made possible, is also wanting.
2. In the state of fallen nature one never resists interior grace.
3. In order to merit or demerit in the state of fallen nature, freedom from necessity is not required in man, but freedom from external compulsion is sufficient.
4. The Semipelagians admitted the necessity of a prevenient interior grace for each act, even for the beginning of faith; and in this they were heretics, because they wished this grace to be such that the human will could either resist or obey.
5. It is Semipelagian to say that Christ died or shed His blood for all men without exception.
— Innocent X, bull Cum occasione (31 May 1653), the five propositions of Jansen’s Augustinus, Denzinger §§2001–2007, source.2 The first four were condemned outright (the first as “rash, impious, blasphemous… and heretical,” the next three as “heretical”); the fifth was condemned as “false… and, understood in this sense, that Christ died for the salvation of the predestined [only],… heretical.” Read against the timeline, the condemned propositions are Jansen’s (and Gottschalk’s) hard Augustinianism stated as bluntly as possible: grace so efficacious it cannot be resisted (props. 2, 4), commands that bind even where the grace to keep them is withheld (prop. 1), a liberty that needs only freedom from external compulsion, not from interior necessity (prop. 3), and a redemption limited to the elect (prop. 5). In condemning them Rome drew, from the Augustinian side, the same line Orange had drawn from the Pelagian side.
Cornelius Jansen, Augustinus (Louvain, 1640), theses on grace, the two delectations, the passive will, and the denial of purely sufficient grace, as characterized (with the “two arms of a balance” image expressly attributed to Jansenius) in the Catholic Encyclopedia, “Jansenius and Jansenism”. This is a secondary (and unsympathetic) characterization; no English translation of the Latin Augustinus is quoted directly here. ↩
Innocent X, bull Cum occasione (31 May 1653), condemning five propositions of Cornelius Jansen’s Augustinus — Denzinger §§2001–2007 (older numbering §§1092–1096); verbatim English (Denzinger, with the full censures) at rosarychurch.net, and a full translation of the bull itself at Wikisource. Cf. the Catholic Encyclopedia, “Jansenius and Jansenism” (the first four condemned absolutely, the fifth “if understood in the sense that Christ died only for the predestined”). ↩
For Jansen’s life (b. 28 Oct. 1585 at Accoi, near Leerdam, Holland; studied at Louvain; associate of Jean du Verger de Hauranne, the later abbé de Saint-Cyran; consecrated bishop of Ypres 1636; d. of plague 6 May 1638; the Augustinus printed posthumously 1640) and for the ensuing controversy (Arnauld and Port-Royal; Pascal’s Provinciales, 1656; the fact/right distinction; the formulary), see the Catholic Encyclopedia, “Jansenius and Jansenism.” (This bishop of Ypres is not to be confused with the earlier exegete Cornelius Jansenius of Ghent, 1510–1576.) ↩