HistoricalChristian.Faith

Albertus Magnus on the living heavens

Dates: c. 1255 (the natural-philosophy works, above all De caelo et mundo); Albert c. 1200–1280 · Wikipedia
Summary: Aquinas’ own teacher is a full witness on the angelic-mover strand — and, on the ensoulment sub-question, the outlier on the other side of his pupil. Albert holds unambiguously that the celestial spheres are moved by separate immaterial intelligences ranked beneath God, and that this celestial motion is the channel through which form and causal power descend to the world below — his emblematic axiom, “every work of nature is the work of an intelligence.” But where Aquinas would deny the heavens any indwelling soul, Albert, reading Aristotle through Averroes, develops a doctrine of celestial souls: the mover of a sphere is an intellectual soul-form, not the vegetative-sensitive soul of an “animal.” He carefully distinguishes the philosophers’ “intelligences” from the theologians’ angels and, by the scholars’ account, never fully settles whether to call the movers souls or to identify them with angels. So he reinforces the mover consensus while softening the anti-ensoulment edge that Basil and Aquinas hold.

Every work of nature is the work of an intelligence

Albert’s signature principle ties the whole visible order to the intellects that turn the heavens. Natural things are produced by those celestial intelligences as a house is produced by the architect who moves his tools; the form realized in nature descends from the intelligence that moves the spheres:

…quod totum opus naturae est opus intelligentiae: quia aliter non esset ad finem determinatum…

— “…that the whole work of nature is the work of an intelligence: because otherwise it would not be directed to a determinate end…” (Metaphysica IV, tract. 3, cap. 1, Logic Museum). The “intelligence” here is precisely the mover of the celestial spheres: on Albert’s cosmology the form conceived by “the intelligence of the universe, that is, the mover of the spheres,” is the primary formative principle in the generation of things below, flowing down as a virtus formativa through the celestial rays and motions. The heavens are governed by mind, and their motion carries that governance to the earth.1

The mover of the sphere — and the celestial soul

In De caelo et mundo Albert takes up directly what moves the heaven and whether it is animate. Following Aristotle (Physics VIII, Metaphysics XII) but going beyond him, and drawing on Averroes and, behind him, Alexander of Aphrodisias, he gives an explicit account of a celestial soul — a mover that is intellectual, not the vegetative and sensitive soul that would make the heaven an “animal” in the crude sense. He keeps two vocabularies apart: the philosophers’ “intelligences,” the separate substances that move the spheres, and the theologians’ angels of the Pseudo-Dionysian hierarchy. On the standard reading of his corpus he does not finally decide whether the celestial movers should be called souls, and whether they are to be identified with the angels — the point at which he is genuinely more open to a form of animate heaven than his pupil.2

Notes

Sources


  1. Albertus Magnus, Metaphysica lib. IV, tract. 3, cap. 1 (“De opinione Pythagorae…”), Latin text at The Logic Museum: “…quod totum opus naturae est opus intelligentiae…” The axiom’s cosmological sense — the intelligences that move the spheres as the formative source of things below (the virtus formativa flowing through the celestial motions) — is traced in Adam Takahashi, “Nature, Formative Power and Intellect in the Natural Philosophy of Albert the Great,” Early Science and Medicine 13 (2008) 451–481, PDF; on the axiom’s history see James A. Weisheipl, “The Axiom ‘Opus naturae est opus intelligentiae’ and Its Origins,” in Albertus Magnus, Doctor Universalis 1280/1980 (Mainz, 1980), 441–463. ↩

  2. Albertus Magnus, De caelo et mundo lib. II, tract. 3 (on the mover of the heaven and its animation), critical edition P. Hossfeld, Editio Coloniensis 5/1 (Münster: Aschendorff, 1971); older text in the Borgnet Opera omnia vol. 4, digitized at archive.org. That Albert “elaborated on the nature of celestial souls and in so doing went clearly beyond Aristotle’s original discussion” is the finding of Adam Takahashi, Interpreting Aristotle’s Cosmos: Albert the Great as a Reader of Averroes (Radboud Univ., 2017), ch. 2, and “Albert the Great as a Reader of Averroes… the Celestial Soul,” Early Science and Medicine 13 (2008) 451–481, PDF; the Stanford Encyclopedia notes Albert “seems to struggle mightily to make up his mind for good” on the animation of the celestial bodies and their identification with angels, while holding that “the intelligences move the cosmic spheres and illuminate the human soul” (SEP, “Albert the Great”). ↩