Dates: active c. 1117 – c. 1131 (burned at the stake by a mob at Saint-Gilles, near Nîmes; the timeline anchors him at c. 1131, the close of his ministry) · Wikipedia
Summary: A credobaptist witness — and the best-attested medieval opponent of infant baptism, roughly four centuries before the Anabaptists. An itinerant preacher in Provence and Languedoc, Peter of Bruys taught that baptism saves only where personal faith precedes it, so that the baptism of infants — who cannot yet believe — is worthless, and those baptized in infancy must receive the true baptism once they come to faith. His teaching survives only in the reports of his opponents, chiefly Peter the Venerable’s Contra Petrobrusianos (c. 1139–1140), but on the baptismal question it is a genuine anticipation of the believers’-baptism principle — not, as with the dualist Cathars, a rejection of the material sacrament as such.
Peter of Bruys left no writings of his own; his doctrine is known from the treatise the abbot of Cluny, Peter the Venerable, wrote against his followers. Its opening lists five Petrobrusian errors, of which the first is the rejection of infant baptism — summarized by Philip Schaff:
The baptism of persons before they have reached the years of discretion is invalid. Believers’ baptism was based upon Mark 16:16, and children, growing up, were rebaptized.
— Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 5, on Peter de Bruys.1 The Catholic Encyclopedia makes the underlying logic exact — and, importantly, shows that Peter did not reject water baptism as such but revalued it as a believer’s rite:
In his system baptism is indeed a necessary condition for salvation, but it is baptism preceded by personal faith, so that its administration to infants is worthless.
— N. A. Weber, “Petrobrusians,” Catholic Encyclopedia (1913).2 This is the same axis the credobaptist tradition would later contest: baptism belongs to the one who can believe for himself, so a newborn is no fit subject — the broad faith-precedes-baptism case, read here off Mark 16:16 (“He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved”) four hundred years before Menno rested the same exclusion on the same verse.
The fullest report of the Petrobrusian argument, translated from Peter the Venerable’s treatise, puts the case in the dissenters’ own reported words — including their insistence (later echoed by the Anabaptists, from whom the very name comes) that what they did was not re-baptism at all, since the infant washing had never been a real baptism:
Hence infants, although they are baptized by you, nevertheless, because they cannot believe, since they are as yet too young, are not at all saved… But we wait for the time when a person, after he has known God, is ready to believe on Him, and so baptize him – not rebaptize him, as you accuse us – but baptize him, since he had not before been baptized with baptism which cleanses from sin.
— Peter the Venerable, Contra Petrobrusianos, trans. in J. C. Reagan, “Did the Petrobrusians Teach Salvation by Faith Alone?” The Journal of Religion 7 (1927), p. 89.3 Peter the Venerable’s own counter is the mirror-image of the whole paedobaptist case — if the martyrs are saved by faith without baptism, why can children not be saved “by baptism alone without faith?” — which concedes, in passing, that his opponents made faith the thing baptism answers to.4
Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 5: The Middle Ages, A.D. 1049–1294 (“New Sects”), on Peter de Bruys and the five errors of the Petrobrusians (Christian Classics Ethereal Library); the underlying source is Peter the Venerable, Contra Petrobrusianos haereticos (c. 1139–1140; critical Latin ed. J. V. Fearns, Corpus Christianorum Continuatio Mediaevalis X, 1968; Patrologia Latina 189, 719–850) ↩
N. A. Weber, “Petrobrusians,” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 11 (New York: Robert Appleton Co., 1911; New Advent) (“baptism preceded by personal faith, so that its administration to infants is worthless”) ↩
Peter the Venerable, Contra Petrobrusianos, translated in Joseph Cowley Reagan, “Did the Petrobrusians Teach Salvation by Faith Alone? A Study in Twelfth-Century Heresy,” The Journal of Religion 7:1 (January 1927), pp. 81–91, quotation at p. 89 (University of Chicago Press; JSTOR) ↩
Reagan, “Did the Petrobrusians Teach Salvation by Faith Alone?” The Journal of Religion 7 (1927), p. 89 (Peter the Venerable’s rejoinder: “If the Martyrs are saved by their faith alone without baptism, why cannot children be saved by baptism alone without faith?”); on Peter of Bruys as a genuine believers’-baptism advocate rather than a dualist — he and Henry of Lausanne compelled clergy to marry, unlike the Cathars — see the same article and Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 5; on the dates (active c. 1117–c. 1131, burned at Saint-Gilles) and Henry of Lausanne, “Peter of Bruys,” Wikipedia and Weber, “Petrobrusians” (New Advent) ↩