HistoricalChristian.Faith

John of Montson and the Paris condemnation of 1387

Dates: 1387 (condemnation at Paris) · Wikipedia
Summary: John of Montson (Juan de Monzón / Johannes de Montesono), an Aragonese Dominican and Paris master of theology, taught that Mary was conceived in original sin like every other child of Adam and that the immaculist opinion was heretical. The Paris theology faculty condemned fourteen of his propositions; the Bishop of Paris excommunicated defenders of them; Montson appealed to Avignon and then fled. The Order of Preachers was expelled from the University. The sharpest maculist statement of the medieval dispute and the institutional turning point that hardened Paris into an immaculist stronghold. Denies claim (b).

Claims & evidence

The thesis: Mary conceived in original sin, and the contrary view heretical

Montson lectured at the Dominican convent of St-Jacques and obtained his mastership in theology at Paris in 1387. Taking the Dominican side of the Franciscan–Dominican quarrel, he taught that the Blessed Virgin was conceived in original sin like all Adam’s descendants — and, going further, that the opposite (immaculist) opinion was heretical. It was this second charge, not the maculist view itself, that the officially neutral faculty demanded he retract. This is the plainest denial of claim (b) put on the record by a member of the Order of Preachers; defenders of the doctrine later observed that no Dominican writer is cited as having denied Mary’s privilege in these terms before 1387.

The condemnation of the fourteen propositions

The faculty of theology condemned fourteen propositions drawn from his lectures, warned him privately and then publicly to retract, and when he refused referred the matter to Pierre d’Orgemont, Bishop of Paris, “who promulgated a decree of excommunication against all who should defend the forbidden theses.”1

The appeal, the flight, and the delegates

Montson appealed to the Avignon pope Clement VII, who summoned both him and the university’s delegates. Foreseeing defeat, and despite an order to remain at Avignon under pain of excommunication, he secretly withdrew into Aragon and thence to Sicily, transferring his allegiance to Clement’s Roman rival Urban VI. Among the university delegates who pressed the case were Pierre d’Ailly (whom Denifle judged the likely drafter of the faculty’s condemnatory letters) and the young Jean Gerson. Tellingly, they argued not on the doctrine’s truth but on the university’s right to police its own teachers:

John of Montson appealed to Pope Clement VII at Avignon, and Pierre d’Ailly, Gerson and the other university delegates, while they personally supported the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception, were content to rest their case upon the legal rights of the university to test in its own way its theological teachers.

— Encyclopædia Britannica (1911), “Gerson, John.”2

The Dominicans expelled from Paris

As a direct consequence of the affair the Order of Preachers, refusing to submit to the decision, withdrew from the University of Paris (c. 1389) and did not return until 1403 — an exclusion of roughly fourteen years.3 The episode fixed Paris — the leading theology faculty of Latin Christendom — as an immaculist bastion, and it is the immediate root of the university’s 1497 oath requiring every member to swear to defend the Immaculate Conception.

Notes

Sources


  1. “John of Montesono,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1913) (the fourteen condemned propositions, Bishop Pierre d’Orgemont’s decree of excommunication, the appeal to Clement VII, and the flight); reprinted at Catholic Answers. The “no Dominican cited denying the privilege before 1387” observation is that of Charles-René Billuart, reported secondhand (⚠ unverified against Billuart’s Latin). ↩

  2. “Gerson, John,” Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed., 1911) (the delegates’ posture — d’Ailly and Gerson resting the case on the university’s legal rights rather than the doctrine’s truth). ↩

  3. The documentary record of the affair — the 1387–89 condemnation, the fourteen propositions, Bishop d’Orgemont’s excommunication, and the appeal to Clement VII — is edited in H. Denifle & E. Chatelain, Chartularium Universitatis Parisiensis, vol. III (Paris, 1894), nos./pp. 486–533 (the readmission act itself falls in vol. IV, covering 1394–1452). For the Dominicans’ withdrawal and their return in 1403, Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. VI: they “refused to bow to the decision, left the university and did not return till 1403.” The allegiance switch to Urban VI: “John of Montson” (Wikipedia). ↩