Dates: c. 1655 (lived 1596–1676) · Wikipedia
Summary: La Peyrère, a French Calvinist scholar and secretary to the Prince de Condé, is the
first denier of the universal Flood on this timeline — the hinge the "who first denied the Flood?" question turns on.
In Prae-Adamitae (Amsterdam, 1655; English Men before Adam, 1656) he argued that men existed
before Adam — Adam being the father of the Jews only, not of all mankind — and drew from it the consequence
that the Deluge judged the Jews' sins alone and overflowed only "Palestine, and the Land of the Jews,"
leaving the pre-Adamite Gentile nations of the wider world untouched. He denied the Flood's universality,
not its reality: a real Noah and a real (local) Deluge remained. The book was condemned and publicly burned
at Paris in 1656; La Peyrère was arrested, recanted before Pope Alexander VII, and converted to Catholicism (1657),
but his method — corrupt biblical texts, denial that Moses wrote a universal history — fed Spinoza, Richard Simon,
and the rise of higher criticism.
Give us leave to discusse this last miracle of the flood of Noah, which is believ'd to have overflow'd the kingdoms of the earth with most mighty overflowings, and which I rather believe overflow'd only Palestine, and the Land of the Jews. The causes of this conjecture are chiefly, the causes of the Deluge…
— A Theological System upon that Presupposition, that Men were before Adam (in Men before Adam, London, 1656), Book 4, ch. 7, p. 239, Internet Archive. La Peyrère opens the chapter — headed "That the Flood of Noah was not upon the whole earth, but only upon the Land of the Jews. Not to destroy all men, but only the Jews" — by making the Flood turn on its cause: the sins for which it was sent were the Jews' sins, so the judgment fell only where those sinners were. He states the thesis flatly a few pages on: "if we will take notice of the thing and not of the words, it will appear, that the Deluge came only upon the Land of the Jews, and not upon the whole world."1
…the design of Moses in setting down Adam, was not to mention the first of mankinde, but the Father of the Jews, whose peculiar Historie he wrote, and not the History of all Nations.
— A Theological System, Book 3, p. 218 (cf. the chapter heading, p. 135: "Adam was the first and father of the Jews, not of all men"), Internet Archive. This is the root of the local Flood. If Adam fathered the Jews only and Gentile nations already peopled the earth, then the Flood — a punishment of the Jews — need not, and on La Peyrère's reading did not, reach them: "God did not that time send the fear of the Jews upon the Nations that dwelt in China, America, the South, or Greenland." He reads the universal-sounding language of Genesis 7 as the "high stile" of a writer describing his own land — "the high mountains of Palestine… the whole heaven, was that which covered Palestine" — since "it is ordinary to assign every Country its own heaven."2
It is clear, that this Deluge was peculiar to the Jews, not universal in all Nations, by that which is written of the Dove, which Noe sent out, and she return'd to him at night.
— A Theological System, Book 4, ch. 8, p. 244, Internet Archive. His props are exegetical and physical: the dove returned with a green olive branch that a year-long, mud-burying worldwide flood could not have spared, so (he argues) it "flew over all the waters of the Deluge, and in the higher fields of Asia" found the branch on land the flood never reached; and the "natural descent of waters" from the ark's resting-place tells the same way. The event is real — a real Noah, a real ark, real waters — but bounded to one region. He is thus the first to break the universal reading while still affirming the Deluge itself: he denies its universality, not its reality.3
Isaac La Peyrère, A Theological System upon that Presupposition, that Men were before Adam, Book 4, ch. 7, pp. 239, 243 — bound with Men before Adam (London, 1656), the English translation of Prae-Adamitae (Amsterdam, 1655): "…which I rather believe overflow'd only Palestine, and the Land of the Jews" (p. 239); "it will appear, that the Deluge came only upon the Land of the Jews, and not upon the whole world" (p. 243). Internet Archive (page-image scan); transcription at EEBO-TCP (A70514). Long-s normalized to s; spelling otherwise original. ↩
La Peyrère, A Theological System, Book 3, pp. 135, 218–219, and Book 4, ch. 7, p. 243 (Men before Adam, London, 1656): "Adam was the first and father of the Jews, not of all men" (ch. heading, p. 135); "the design of Moses in setting down Adam, was not to mention the first of mankinde, but the Father of the Jews" (p. 218); "God did not that time send the fear of the Jews upon the Nations that dwelt in China, America, the South, or Greenland" and "the high mountains of Palestine… the whole heaven, was that which covered Palestine… it is ordinary to assign every Country its own heaven" (p. 243). Internet Archive; EEBO-TCP (A70514). ↩
La Peyrère, A Theological System, Book 4, ch. 8, p. 244 (Men before Adam, London, 1656): "It is clear, that this Deluge was peculiar to the Jews, not universal in all Nations, by that which is written of the Dove, which Noe sent out… That that Dove being sent from the mountains of Armenia, flew over all the waters of the Deluge, and in the higher fields of Asia" found the olive branch. Internet Archive; EEBO-TCP (A70514). On the biography, condemnation, recantation, and influence, and on the Vossius pairing, see Britannica, "Prae-Adamitae" and Eric Jorink, "'Horrible and Blasphemous': Isaac la Peyrère, Isaac Vossius and the Emergence of Radical Biblical Criticism in the Dutch Republic," in Nature and Scripture in the Abrahamic Religions: Up to 1700, ed. J. M. van der Meer & S. Mandelbrote (Leiden: Brill, 2008), pp. 429–450, academia.edu; on Vossius's "local and partial deluge," Martin Schook's Diatriba qua probatur Noachi diluvium toti terrarum orbi incubuisse (1662), noted in the Dictionary of National Biography. ↩