Dates: the modern revival, c. 2015–present (Jeremy Sexton's Westminster Theological Journal
article 2015; Sexton & Smith, "Primeval Chronology Restored," 2016; Henry B. Smith Jr.'s ICC paper 2018) ·
ABR Genesis 5 & 11 Project
Summary: The concluding witness on the timeline — the point where the long-vs-short reckoning that
Eusebius, Augustine, and Ussher took different sides of is a live scholarly dispute again, now argued with the tools of
manuscript criticism. Two camps: the Septuagint-priority revival of Henry B. Smith Jr. and the
Associates for Biblical Research (the Genesis 5 & 11 Research Project), holding that the longer Greek figures are
original and the Hebrew was deliberately shortened after AD 70; and the Masoretic-priority defence
of Creation Ministries International (Lita Cosner/Sanders and Robert Carter) and Andrew Steinmann, holding the received
Hebrew figures the better text. The same textual question the ancient chronographers faced, still unresolved — and
this timeline's modern terminus. The Flood-date consequences are weighed elsewhere and cross-linked below, not
re-argued here.
The twenty-first-century revival of the long chronology is the work of Henry B. Smith Jr. and the Associates for Biblical Research, whose Genesis 5 & 11 Research Project reopened the case that the Septuagint, not the Masoretic Text, preserves the original primeval numbers. Reckoning the Greek begetting-ages Smith fixes the interval from Adam to Abraham at 3,394 years against the Masoretic 2,008, and places Creation at c. 5554 BC and the Flood at c. 3298 BC — roughly a millennium earlier than Ussher. His thesis is not that the Greek merely reads well but that the Hebrew was tampered with:
This paper proposes that the LXX preserves (most of) the original numbers in Genesis 5 and 11. Most of the MT's chronology in Genesis 5 and 11 does not represent the original text, and is the result of a deliberate and systematic post–AD 70 corruption.
The revival thus reaches back and picks up exactly the charge Eusebius first made in the fourth century — that the rabbis curtailed the Hebrew figures — and presses it with the full apparatus of modern textual criticism, gathering the pre-Christian and patristic witnesses to a long chronology (Demetrius, Eupolemus, Pseudo-Philo, Josephus, Africanus) as evidence that the divergence predates any Christian–Jewish polemic.1 The project's findings are to be gathered in a forthcoming book, From Adam to Abraham: The Case for the Septuagint's Chronology in Genesis 5 and 11.
The revival turned on a prior, semantic argument by Jeremy Sexton, whose 2015 Westminster Theological Journal article "Who Was Born When Enosh Was 90?" reevaluated William Henry Green's classic "chronological gaps" thesis — the reading (assumed by most conservatives since 1890) that the Genesis 5 and 11 formula "when X had lived n years he begat Y" need not name an immediate son, so the ages cannot be summed into a continuous chronology. Sexton granted that the Hebrew hiphil of yālad could occasionally mean "became the ancestor of" (allowing a genealogical gap), but showed that even so the descendant is still born at the stated age — so the reading yields genealogical gaps but not chronological ones, and the numbers remain a running clock.2 That result is load-bearing for the whole revival: if the ages are a genuine chronology with no gaps to hide in, then which set of ages is original becomes the decisive question — which is why Smith's textual case and Sexton's exegetical one converged into a single program (their joint "Primeval Chronology Restored," 2016). It also cuts squarely across one of the counter-arguments to a literal-Flood date weighed on this wiki — the point that the genealogies are open lists, not calendars, shown by the extra Cainan the Greek carries and Luke repeats — a tension noted below and left to be weighed on the argument pages, not adjudicated here.
The revival did not go unanswered. Against it stands a Masoretic-priority defence, most fully from Lita Cosner (Sanders) and Robert Carter of Creation Ministries International and, in a mediating key, from Andrew Steinmann, who continued to argue for chronological gaps against Sexton. Sanders' 2025 Answers Research Journal paper "The Textual Superiority of the Masoretic Text of Genesis 5 and 11" puts the case that the shared Septuagint–Samaritan variants point to error in a common Vorlage rather than to an older Greek reading, and that the received Hebrew is the better-preserved text. Its conclusion states the counter-thesis flatly:
This textual analysis provided by this paper shows that the MT is the better-preserved text and that the MT chronology was changed to create the chronologies in the LXX and SP, rather than the LXX or the SP being original.
Smith replied directly ("Setting the Record Straight on the Primeval Chronology of the Septuagint: A Response to Cosner and Carter," 2018), and Steinmann and Sexton exchanged rejoinders in the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society — so the modern dispute is a live, published back-and-forth, not a settled position.3 The exchange is, precisely, the continuation of the ancient quarrel this timeline traces: the same two readings of the same genealogies, now contested on manuscript grounds.
Henry B. Smith Jr., "The Case for the Septuagint's Chronology in Genesis 5 and 11," Associates for Biblical Research (9 May 2019; full paper in Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Creationism [Pittsburgh: Creation Science Fellowship, 2018], 117–132; PDF): "This paper proposes that the LXX preserves (most of) the original numbers in Genesis 5 and 11. Most of the MT's chronology in Genesis 5 and 11 does not represent the original text, and is the result of a deliberate and systematic post–AD 70 corruption," with the Adam–Abraham total of 3,394 years (MT 2,008) and Creation c. 5554 BC / Flood c. 3298 BC. The pre-Christian and patristic attestation Smith gathers (Demetrius, Eupolemus, Pseudo-Philo, Josephus, Theophilus, Africanus) is described on the Septuagint long-chronology argument. The project is the ABR Genesis 5 & 11 Genealogy and Chronology Research Project, whose findings are to appear as From Adam to Abraham: The Case for the Septuagint's Chronology in Genesis 5 and 11. The full text-critical weighing (against Hendel, Tov, Wevers) is on the Genesis-chronology corruption argument. ↩
Jeremy Sexton, "Who Was Born When Enosh Was 90? A Semantic Reevaluation of William Henry Green's Chronological Gaps," Westminster Theological Journal 77, no. 2 (2015): 193–218 (PDF at Associates for Biblical Research; WTJ 77.2 contents), arguing that the hiphil of yālad in Genesis 5 and 11 denotes the birthing of the descendant, so that even the "became the ancestor of" reading yields genealogical but not chronological gaps — the ages remain a continuous chronology. Followed up in Jeremy Sexton, "Evangelicalism's Search for Chronological Gaps in Genesis 5 and 11: A Historical, Hermeneutical, and Linguistic Critique," Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 61, no. 1 (2018): 5–25, and the joint program with Smith: Jeremy Sexton and Henry B. Smith Jr., "Primeval Chronology Restored: Revisiting the Genealogies of Genesis 5 and 11," Bible and Spade 29, no. 2 (2016): 42–49. The countervailing "open list" evidence (the Septuagint's extra Cainan, repeated at Luke 3:36) is set out on the Septuagint long-chronology argument. ↩
Lita Sanders, "The Textual Superiority of the Masoretic Text of Genesis 5 and 11," Answers Research Journal 18 (2025): 183–187: "This textual analysis provided by this paper shows that the MT is the better-preserved text and that the MT chronology was changed to create the chronologies in the LXX and SP, rather than the LXX or the SP being original." The Creation Ministries International defence of the Masoretic figures is put by Lita Cosner and Robert Carter, "The Masoretic text of Genesis 5 and 11 is still the most reliable," to which Smith replied in "Setting the Record Straight on the Primeval Chronology of the Septuagint: A Response to Cosner and Carter," Bible and Spade 31, no. 4 (2018): 114–133. The gaps-vs-no-gaps exchange between Andrew E. Steinmann and Sexton runs through JETS 61, no. 1 (2018) — Sexton's "Andrew E. Steinmann's Search for Chronological Gaps in Genesis 5 and 11: A Rejoinder," 39–45. The rival readings are rated on the Masoretic short chronology and Samaritan Pentateuch chronology pages. ↩