Dates: c. 380 (the dialogue Against Fate, Contra Fatum, composed after a debate at
Constantinople); Gregory c. 335–395 · Wikipedia
Summary: In a short dialogue recording a debate he held at Constantinople with a pagan philosopher who
defended astral fate, Gregory refutes genethlialogy on the familiar free-will ground that his brother
Basil had laid down — but he adds a distinctive empirical argument all his own:
whole cities of people, born at every different hour and under every different sign, are wiped out together "in a single
instant" by an earthquake or a flood, a common fate that no scheme of individual horoscopes can account for. He mocks the
animal-qualities read off the constellations as incoherent, and appeals (like Bardaisan)
to the diversity of national customs, concluding that "destiny and fate seems determined by each person's free will."
The astrologer's claim, as Gregory frames it, is that "fate determines [a person's] life at the hour of birth by the formation of stars, [and] this order remains constant throughout life" — each nativity fixed by a unique configuration of the heavens. Against this Gregory turns a public catastrophe: when a city of Bithynia was destroyed by earthquake and fire, people of every age, rank, and condition — who by hypothesis were born at different hours and so cast under different stars — all perished at the same moment:
Many perished in a single instant: children, infants, those in middle and old age, the free and slaves, victors and vanquished, wealthy and poor, the strong and weak.
— Against Fate, archived English translation. If each of these lives had really been governed by its own separate birth-chart, no single event should have gathered them all into one death at one hour; the shared fate has no shared horoscope behind it. This mass-simultaneous-death argument is Gregory's own contribution to the tradition, not found in Basil's Hexaemeron.1
Like Basil before him, Gregory finds it absurd to read a man's character off the beast a constellation is merely named after — the servility of a bull under the yoke, the profit of a ram's fleece:
You say that Taurus is servile because it [a bull] is under the yoke and that Aries [a ram] represents profit gained from wool.
— Against Fate, archived English translation. The reasoning collapses on inspection: the bull is yoked by force, not by nature, and the ram does not "willingly" yield its wool — so the qualities the astrologers project onto the signs do not even hold of the animals whose names the signs bear.2
Gregory presses a further line that Bardaisan of Edessa had used before him: whole nations, spread under all the same stars as everyone else, keep customs peculiar to themselves — so it is law and choice, not the heavens, that govern conduct. Since a given outrage is practised by one nation alone though its people are born under every sign, the cause cannot lie in the stars:
Since the Persians alone are guilty of such outrageous behavior, it clearly follows that destiny and fate seems determined by each person's free will.
— Against Fate, archived English translation. The conclusion is the standard patristic one — virtue and vice are "in our own power" — but Gregory reaches it by the argument from the diversity of national law rather than by Basil's appeal to reward and punishment.3
Gregory of Nyssa, Against Fate (Contra Fatum), c. 380; Greek in J. A. McDonough, Gregorii Nysseni Opera III.2 (Brill, 1987), PG 45. English translation (translator unattributed): omsgsa.org (also omhksea.org): the astrologer holds that "fate determines [a person's] life at the hour of birth by the formation of stars"; against which, when a Bithynian city fell to earthquake and fire, "Many perished in a single instant: children, infants, those in middle and old age, the free and slaves, victors and vanquished, wealthy and poor, the strong and weak." ↩
Gregory of Nyssa, Against Fate, omsgsa.org: "You say that Taurus is servile because it [a bull] is under the yoke and that Aries [a ram] represents profit gained from wool." Cf. the parallel in his brother Basil, Hexaemeron VI.6 (the Ram, the Bull, the Balance). ↩
Gregory of Nyssa, Against Fate, omsgsa.org: "Since the Persians alone are guilty of such outrageous behavior, it clearly follows that destiny and fate seems determined by each person's free will." The argument from the diversity of national customs is the same one Bardaisan of Edessa pressed c. 200 in The Book of the Laws of Countries. ↩