Dates: b. 1965 · Wikipedia
Summary: The American Orthodox philosopher and theologian David Bentley Hart gives the
tradition its boldest modern statement. Where Balthasar defended a
hope that all may be saved, Hart's That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation
(Yale, 2019) argues the restoration as certain: if Christianity is a coherent whole, he holds,
universalism is the only reading of it that is not self-contradictory. He revives, without reserve, the case
of Origen and Gregory of Nyssa,
resting it on 1 Corinthians 15:28 and on the claim that a God who creates knowing some will be lost forever
is thereby implicated in that loss. As the defining twentieth-first-century universalist statement, he is the
natural counter-pole to Michael McClymond's contemporaneous case against the doctrine.
I mean only that, if Christianity taken as a whole is indeed an entirely coherent and credible system of belief, then the universalist understanding of its message is the only one possible. I say that without the least hesitation or qualification.
— That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2019), p. 3, as reproduced in the Wikipedia summary. This is the thesis that separates Hart from Balthasar's reserve: not “we may hope” but “it must be so.” Hart adds a historical claim — that the universalists were “at their most numerous… in the church's first half millennium,” the very people Augustine dismissed as the misericordes, the “merciful-hearted” — aligning himself with the reading this timeline traces from Origen through Gregory of Nyssa and Isaac of Nineveh.
To say that, on the one hand, God is infinitely good, perfectly just, and inexhaustibly loving, and that, on the other, he has created a world under such terms as oblige him either to impose, or to permit the imposition of, eternal misery on finite rational beings, is simply to embrace a complete contradiction.
— That All Shall Be Saved, as reproduced at Goodreads. Hart's core argument is not exegetical but metaphysical: because God creates freely and from nothing, the final state of creation reveals God's own purpose, so a cosmos in which any rational creature is eternally lost would make that loss part of what God willed in creating — and a God who wills it “is not the savior of all,” in which case “the Kingdom is only a dream, and creation something considerably worse than a nightmare.” The appeal to free will, he argues, cannot rescue the eternal-hell view, since no finite, ignorant, conditioned choice could bear the weight of an infinite and irrevocable consequence.