HistoricalChristian.Faith

David Bentley Hart on universal restoration (apokatastasis)

Dates: b. 1965 · Wikipedia
Summary: The American Orthodox philosopher and theologian David Bentley Hart gives the tradition its boldest modern statement. Where Balthasar defended a hope that all may be saved, Hart's That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (Yale, 2019) argues the restoration as certain: if Christianity is a coherent whole, he holds, universalism is the only reading of it that is not self-contradictory. He revives, without reserve, the case of Origen and Gregory of Nyssa, resting it on 1 Corinthians 15:28 and on the claim that a God who creates knowing some will be lost forever is thereby implicated in that loss. As the defining twentieth-first-century universalist statement, he is the natural counter-pole to Michael McClymond's contemporaneous case against the doctrine.

Claims & evidence

Universalism is the only coherent reading of the Christian message

I mean only that, if Christianity taken as a whole is indeed an entirely coherent and credible system of belief, then the universalist understanding of its message is the only one possible. I say that without the least hesitation or qualification.

— That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2019), p. 3, as reproduced in the Wikipedia summary. This is the thesis that separates Hart from Balthasar's reserve: not “we may hope” but “it must be so.” Hart adds a historical claim — that the universalists were “at their most numerous… in the church's first half millennium,” the very people Augustine dismissed as the misericordes, the “merciful-hearted” — aligning himself with the reading this timeline traces from Origen through Gregory of Nyssa and Isaac of Nineveh.

An eternal hell is a contradiction in the doctrine of God

To say that, on the one hand, God is infinitely good, perfectly just, and inexhaustibly loving, and that, on the other, he has created a world under such terms as oblige him either to impose, or to permit the imposition of, eternal misery on finite rational beings, is simply to embrace a complete contradiction.

— That All Shall Be Saved, as reproduced at Goodreads. Hart's core argument is not exegetical but metaphysical: because God creates freely and from nothing, the final state of creation reveals God's own purpose, so a cosmos in which any rational creature is eternally lost would make that loss part of what God willed in creating — and a God who wills it “is not the savior of all,” in which case “the Kingdom is only a dream, and creation something considerably worse than a nightmare.” The appeal to free will, he argues, cannot rescue the eternal-hell view, since no finite, ignorant, conditioned choice could bear the weight of an infinite and irrevocable consequence.

Notes